Are 5-star recruits worth the hype?

This might seem like a no-brainer, but it is a source of conversation from time to time on message boards such as “Ask the Insiders” at, and it seems as though every year around National Signing Day you can find a new hot take about how recruiting rankings are overrated because not every five-star prospect becomes an All-American and plenty of four- and three-star players turn into big stars.

Comparing Careers: OSU Five-Star Recruits - ohiostate - Scout

So I figured it was time to take a look at the issue, at least from an Ohio State point of view.

Here’s what I found: Comparing Careers: OSU Five-Star Recruits – ohiostate – Scout.

Yes, the five-stars tend to outperform their lower-rated counterparts, but the degree of superiority actually turned out to be higher than I might have expected. And that was without making the same compromises in terms of personnel losses or even recruiting home-state heroes as opposed to national stars.

One thought on “Are 5-star recruits worth the hype?

Leave a Reply